Главная » Периодические издания » Asking right question
2 3 4 ... 15
asking right questions
OMETIMES I FIND MYSELF visualizing a business as though it were a big train.The engineer-CEO sits in the cab, wearing one of those hickory stripe railroad caps. The dials in front of him display the speed, pressure, temperature, and the like. At his hand are levers controlling the throttle, the brake, and so on, along with buzzers and phones to communicate with the crew. In a childrens book,about which I remember everything except the title, theres a train that races from Kalamazoo to Timbuktu. Our familys favorite line, which we always chanted loudly whenever we came to it, was: Slam! Bam! Grease the engine! Throw out the throttle and give it the gun!
But - back to business - what if the engineer has the wrong set of instruments? What if the levers dont connect to anything? What if theres a steam pressure gauge, but the train has an electric motor? What if you have the skills and controls for a train but find yourself in the cockpit of an airplane?
Many managers partly and intuitively understand that the controls they have might not be right for their business. For example, they know its not especially meaningful to measure the return on assets for a company like Microsoft, which has relatively few assets (apart from cash). They understand that economies of scale are a big deal in the automobile industry but that scale effects are markedly smaller in advertising, law, or hotel management. They know that some familiar levers seem irrelevant; they may complain, The stock market doesnt understand us. Theyre less clear on why this is so and what they can do about it.
The Surprising Economics of a People Business takes a revealing and useful look at this issue. Felix Barber and Rainer Strack, quantitatively minded partners at the Boston Consulting Group, have looked inside different kinds of firms to see which levers connect to which cams, gears, and other drivers. What they found is a whole (and very large) class of companies that look different on the outside but are very similar on the inside. These are people businesses, where capital costs are low compared to payroll and where there arent a lot of activities aimed at creating value for the future, such as R&D. This might be true of an entire company or just one unit. IBM is a good example. The economics
of its growing consulting and services business resemble those of an advertising agency like Omnicom or an oilfield services business like Schlum-berger. IBMs hardware side, however, looks like Intel.
A rich stream of consequences flows from this insight and analysis.The most important have to do with making sure that a companys leaders are paying attention to the levers and gauges that are relevant to the businesss perfor-mance.Take a gold standard measurement like Economic Value Added. EVA gives a picture of the true economic profit of a business by recognizing the cost of the capital employed in the business. EVA is the number that tells shareholders whether theyre getting their moneys worth. Executives should care about that and about something else: the steps they can take to increase EVA most effectively. Those steps are different for people-intensive shops than for capital-intensive ones.
Im a little worried that Ive made this all sound more technical than it is. In fact, Barber and Stracks article is full of implications for line managers, human resource executives, CFOs-and the engineer in the cab.
Theres lots more in this issue, including a superb pair of articles that spotlight the strategic and operational risks of moving into new markets. I want to call your attention to one feature in particular: Developing First-Level Leaders by BP executive Andreas Priestland and Dialogos VP Robert Hanig. HBR devotes many pages to the issues senior managers face-how they develop, how they can lead more effectively, and so on. Research shows that first-level man-agers-those work-group supervisors on the front lines of the business - have an enormous effect on performance.
Developing First-Level Leaders takes us inside a major company, BP, to show how it made big improvements in the training and performance of this important group. Make sure you read it.
Thomas A. Stewart
BEAN COUNTER. NUMBER CRUNCHER. PENNY-PINCHER TIGHTWAD. WHAT THEY REALLY MEAN IS THANKS.
HELPING YOU FIND PROFITS IN NEW PLACES.
Corporate Payment Solutions
COLUMBIA BUSINESS SCHOOL
Stake Your Claim to Success
Come to EXECUTIVE EDUCATION at Columbia Business School, where youll hear perspectives from Bogota to Beijing, and develop new approaches to your most pressing business challenges. Our faculty will guide your way to improving your organizations performance and becoming a stronger, more strategic leader. At Columbia, were focused on your results.
Executive Development Program: The Transition to General Management June 5-17
Pricing to Win: Strategies and
Creating Breakthrough Strategy June 12-17
Marketing Management June 19-24
The Columbia Senior Executive Program
Fundamentals of Management: Highlights of an MBA November 6-18
Contact us at 212-854-0616, or visit
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY IN THE CITY OF NEW YORK
Harvard Business Review
Thomas A. Stewart
Leigh Buchanan David Champion Diane L. Coutu Bronwyn Fryer Ben Gerson Paul Hemp Julia Kirby Gardiner Morse M. Ellen Peebles Anand P. Raman
Christina Bortz Lisa Burrell Roberta A. Fusaro Margaret K. Hanshaw Andrew OConnell Andrea Ovans
editor for business
John T. Landry
executive editor and director of derivative
senior production manager
editorial production manager
Jill Manca Annette Trivette
Siobhan C. Ford
Lilith Z.C. Fondulas Amy L. Halliday Susan McCabe
Amy N. Monaghan Annie Noonan Kristin Murphy Romano
editor-at-large harvard Business School pUBLISHING
a note to readers
The views expressed in articles are the authors and not necessarily those of Harvard Business Review, Harvard Business School, or Harvard University. Authors may have consulting or other business relationships with the companies they discuss.
We encourage prospective authors to follow HBRs Guidelines for Authors before submitting manuscripts. To obtain a copy, please go to our Web site at www.hbr.org; write to The Editor, Harvard Business Review, 60 Harvard Way, Boston, MA 02163; or send e-mail to hbr firstname.lastname@example.org. Unsolicited manuscripts will be returned only if accompanied by a self-addressed stamped envelope.
60 Harvard Way, Boston, MA 02163 617-783-7410; fax: 617-783-7493 www.harvardbusinessonline.org
Volume 83, Number 6 June 2005
Printed in the U.S.A.
OCTOBER 5-7, 2005 LES FONTAINES I CHANTILLY, FRANCE
THE RETURN TO GROWTH: ALIGNING STRATEGIC, TECHNOLOGICAL, AND HUMAN ASSETS
Join a select gathering of strategy-setting executives and management thought leaders from Europe, Asia, and the Americas addressing critical business issues that have an impact on growth.
Burning Questions is unique. No droning speeches. No endless slide decks. Each session is provocative and discussion-based. Your voice is needed. Apply today!
Apply online: www.burningquestions.com
Les Fontaines has been purpose-built to facilitate executive meetings. From the
historic chateau to the state-of-the-art meeting facilities, it is the perfect setting for executives to gather, discuss, absorb, and regenerate.
HARVAR D BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING CONFERENCES
Featured Speakers The Burning Questions
Partial list of this years speakers:
JOHN BECK, President, Northstar Leadership Group, co-author, Got Game
CECILE BONNEFOND, President and CEO, Veuve Cliquot
MARK BOOTH, CEO, NetJets Europe
WALTER KIECHEL, Editor at Large, Harvard Business School Publishing
RENEE MAUBORGNE, INSEAD, co-author, Blue Ocean Strategy
KENNETH McGEE, Vice President, Gartner Group, co-author, Heads Up
PRASHANT SAHNI, CEO, Tecnovate
THOMAS A. STEWART, Editor, Harvard Business Review
DON SULL, London Business School, author, Revival of the Fittest
KELVIN BOLLI-THOMPSON, Partner, Heidrick & Struggles
WIL WHITESTONE, President, Virgin Galactic
LAUNCHING GROWTH: Where Is Growth Now?
PULLING THE GROWTH TRIGGER: M&A, Alliance, or Internal Investment?
Who Can Lead the New Global Organization? MANAGING:
Is the Next Generation Ready for You- and Are You Ready for It?
Is Low Cost Really the Only Strategy? RISK/RETURN:
Is Your Company Too Risk Averse?
Harvard Business Review
Managers who want to get the new innovation paradigm should check out [Rotmans] MBA programs.
(BusinessWeek online, March 7, 2005)
- Bruce Nussbaum,
Editorial Page Editor, BusinessWeek
Find out what thought leaders already know.
Order your free copy of
A New Way to Think:
The Best of Rotman Magazine
www.rotman.utoronto.ca/best e: email@example.com т: 416-946-0103
Joseph L. Rotman School of Management University of Toronto
Cathryn Cronin Cranston
TURN TRIAL BY FIRE INTO
TRIAL BY WARM EMBERS.
You cant eliminate the challenges that new managers face. But you can certainly minimize them. Introducing Stepping Up to Management, an
online program specifically designed to help newly promoted managers gain immediate success. Stepping Up to Management allows managers to learn their jobs while performing their jobs, with content thats integrated into their day-to-day workflow. It also gives organizations the ability to groom future leaders every step of the way.
Visit www.eLearning.hbsp.org/SUM to find out more.
HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING
Ref Code: 9969
Edward D. Crowley
Bruce W. Rhodes
Adrienne M. Spelker
assistant advertising MANAGER
Ashley C. Hartmann
worldwide advertising offices
advertising director - worldwide
MARkETING AND OPERATIONS
For all other inquiries, please call 212-872-9280.
For advertising contact information, please visit our Web site at www.hbradsales.com.
SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE INFORMATION U.S. AND CANADA
800-274-3214; fax: 902-563-4807 Rates per year: U.S., $129; Canada, u.s.$139
44-1858-438868; fax: 44-1858-468969
Rates per year: u.s.$165; Mexico, u.s.$139
Copyright © 2005 Harvard Business School
Publishing Corporation. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced
or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and
retrieval system, without written permission.
WHAT EXCITES US MOST ABOUT AUSTRALIA IS ITS INTERNATIONALLY RESPECTED RESEARCHERS.
SCIENCE IS AT THE HEART OF EVERYTHING WE DO. PARTNERING FOR OVER A DECADE WITH ESTABLISHED NAMES SUCH AS CSIRO-AUSTRALIAS SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH ORGANISATION-AND A HOST OF LEADING AUSTRALIAN UNIVERSITY RESEARCH CENTERS, HAS CONTRIBUTED SIGNIFICANTLY TO OUR GLOBAL CAPABILITIES AND COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE.
CHAD HOLLIDAY, CHAIRMAN AND CEO, DUPONT.
Australia the place to grow your business in the worlds fastest growing region
With almost half of global trade now focussed in the Asia-Pacific-the worlds fastest growing region-Australia is the contemporary business base for Asia-Pacific investment.
Australias unique geographic and time zone advantage, its cultural affinity with Asia and its American/European business environment make it your perfect business bridge to Asia.
Services account for almost 80% of economic activity in Australia. This fact, coupled with our strong resources industries, highly skilled and multilingual workforce, excellent R&D capability and efficient governance practices make Australia an ideal investment location.
Australia, its the ideal location to grow your business.
DuPont is a science company. Founded in 1802, DuPont puts science to work by creating sustainable solutions essential to a better, safer, healthier life for people everywhere. With an annual turnover of $US27 billion, 55,000 employees and operating in more than 70 countries, DuPont has more than 40 research and development and customer service labs in the United States, and more than 35 labs in 11 other countries.
In Australia, DuPont has active R&D programs operating with three leading research centers. Such is its commitment to Australian research, DuPont has launched an annual awards program to recognize innovation that improves Australias competitiveness and illustrates the countrys innovative culture.
DuPont has been in Australia for more than 50 years. It offers a wide range of innovative products and services for markets including agriculture, nutrition, electronics, communications, safety and protection, home and construction, transportation and protective apparel.
Dont make an investment decision in the Asia-Pacific without visiting www.investaustralia.com
AUSTRALIA AT A GLANCE
Most resilient economy in the world for the third successive year (WCY 2004)
One of the lowest cost business destinations in the developed world (KPMG 2004)
Lowest risk of political instability in the Asia-Pacific region (WCY 2004)
Most multilingual workforce in the Asia-Pacific region (ABS 2004)
Easiest place in the world to start a business (World Bank 2005)
Number one place in the Asia-Pacific region where expatriate staff want to live and work (EIU 2004)
Fourth largest investment funds under management in the world - US$558b (FEFSI)
Strong Government support for research and development through A$8.3 billion innovation strategy
Modern intellectual property regime ranked first in the Asia-Pacific (WCY 2004)
Audi, Never Follow, A3 and the four rings emblem are registered trademarks of AUDI AG. SD is a registered trademark of the SD Card Association. ©2005 Audi of America, Inc.
Never Follow audiusa.com/A3
Know where you are before you get there. With Audi Navigation plus, the A3 opens a new gateway to luxury. An intuitive control panel, with a secondary Driver Information Display screen, allows you to keep your eyes on the road, while dual MP3 SD® slots let you customize a soundtrack for the road ahead. Its greater to lead than follow.
A survey of ideas, trends, people, and practices on the business horizon.
The Eureka Myth
by HAROLD EVANS
Innovation, cast as the triumph of human imagination, may be the most romantic discipline in business. And the eureka moment, that epiphany of total clarity in which a breakthrough invention or discovery occurs, is the most romantic aspect of innovation. In fact,the eureka moment still looms so large in the folklore of business that it overshadows the historically far more important matter of how an invention reaches the marketplace as a practical innovation. As companies turn their sights anew to top-line growth, it is time to see the eureka
moment - indeed the whole gestalt of breakthrough thinking - for what it is: largely a myth.
Admittedly, the eureka myth is seductive. Thomas Edison, who usually stressed that invention was the easy bit, forgot his own i%-inspiration-to-99%-perspiration rule in describing to a newspaper reporter how the incandescent lightbulb came to him as a gift from the gods. The reporter wrote: Sitting one night in his laboratory, Edison began abstractedly rolling between his fingers a piece of compressed lampblack mixed with tar for
use in his telephone....His thoughts continued far away, his fingers meanwhile mechanically rolling over the little piece of tarred lampblack until it had become a slender filament. In fact, Edisons laboratory notebooks suggest that he had considered carbon early on but discarded it in favor of platinum because carbon burned up too quickly. It was a new prospect - evacuating most of the air from the bulb - that induced Edison to return to carbon.
The trouble with the eureka myth is that it causes managers and investors to
overestimate the pace of invention and underestimate the fortitude required to move from the early stages of discovery to a marketable product. Thomas Watson, Jr., is one of the few who took -and took sustenance from - a more realistic view. In the 1950s, Watson struggled to move IBM from punched cards to computers, something a hundred times faster that we didnt understand, he later wrote. What kept him going through this grueling process? He thought of the Wright brothers, moving doggedly from one problem to the next, any one of which could have grounded them for good, as Watson told it. In the popular imagination, the Wright brothers1903 flight at Kitty Hawk kicked off the age of aviation. But as Watson, a wartime pilot, knew, it took four more years of hard, secretive labor before the Wrights were able to demonstrate flight that was sufficiently sustained to convince a skeptical world.
Some seemingly obvious innovations had much longer gestation periods. Malcolm McLean was a 24-year-old truck driver waiting for his cotton bales to be unloaded at a seaport when it occurred to him how much easier it would be just to drive the truck onto the ship. But it was 20 years before he transmuted the idea into container shipping. His IdealX containership sailed from Port Newark, New Jersey, on April 26,1956, effectively initiating globalization.
The eureka moment is a hugely attractive idea,full of drama. But the act of inventing and improving is far more often a long, hard slog. And the act of capitalizing on invention -of managing the transition from a brain wave to the bustle of the marketplace - is the really hard part.
So declare yourself an innovation company and celebrate creativity, by all means.Then treat your employees to a little seminar in business history that emphasizes real-life time frames and the numbing necessity of trial and error, trial and error, trial and error. The great busi-
ness stories make wonderful fodder for such an education, but dont neglect your own archives. (How many of your employees know what labor went into producing and bringing to market your
companys core products? Do you?) And if your innovators get discouraged, tell them about the inventor who tried 3,000 different materials - including cedar shavings, coconut hair, twine, fishing line,
HOW THEY DID IT
Outsourcing Integration c.
Postmerger integrations are tough. Generally, the acquirer puts the targets distinctive capabilities under its own management and then struggles to pull the two companies operations together. Managers often end up plugging holes in dikes instead of focusing on the core business, and, when they finally emerge from this distraction, they often find that their customers have wandered off and competitors have moved in. Its no wonder that acquisitions so often destroy value.
If integration is so hard, why not outsource it? Thats essentially what Hungarys MOL Group, a $7 billion energy company, did when it outsourced its finance and accounting, treasury, tax, and information technology processes in 2001. MOL plans to become a dominant player in consolidating the central European oil and gas industry. Outsourcing its support activities, says CFO Michel-Marc Delcommune, allows company managers to sidestep the distraction of aligning accounting systems and integrating staff during acquisitions and to stay focused on MOLs core operations and aggressive acquisition strategy. According to Delcommune, when MOL acquired full control of Slovnaft, a $2 billion Slovakian energy company, in 2004, the efficiency of the postmerger integration was palpable. Because the acquisition took place in two steps-MOL had bought 36% of Slovnaft and options for the rest in 2000-the company had time to ready itself for the full merger on the horizon and deliberately delegate postmerger integration to its outsourcing
This made all the difference, Delcommune says. To integrate Slovnaft, the management team assembled 26 task forces to address all the critical business processes, from how the company set wholesale prices to how it managed the supply chain. By contrast, MOL spent none of its management resources on integrating the back office.
Its hard to measure the value of efficient integration and undistracted management. But profits and revenues are easy to track. Between 2000 and 2003, MOLs sales doubled to $7.3 billion and its profits quintupled to $478 million; 2004 profits are expected to top $1 billion. Slovnaft turned its 2000 financial losses into a $400 million profit in 2004. That growth would have been hard to achieve, Delcommune says, if MOL had kept the back office in-house.
jane c. under (firstname.lastname@example.org) is a director of research at the Accenture Institute for High Performance Business in Wellesley, Massachusetts. She is the author of Outsourcing for Radical Change (Amacom, 2004). Reprint F0506B
2 3 4 ... 15
© 2003 GARUN.RU.
Копирование материалов запрещено.